Buying Guide Things to consider when buying a softball glove. When buying softball gloves, size is not the only concern. The fact is that there are many factors that you need to consider, including the type of glove, material, webbing, and more. Slow Pitch Vs. Fastpitch We recommend a larger slowpitch glove if you are in a catcher or pitcher position. On the other hand, for catching a flyball, you can’t go wrong with a fastpitch softball glove designed to withstand wear and tear. Material There is no denying that the material significantly affects a softball glove’s comfort, durability, and longevity. Softball gloves are usually made of full-grain leather. Yet, some manufacturers use synthetic leather. Cowhide Cowhide leather gloves, which range from medium to heavy in weight, are ideal for young players. It is faster to break in these gloves, but they require maintenance and care. Synthetic Leather Synthetic leather gloves are also easy to “break in” and comfortable. Moreover, t...